Girls Varsity Soccer

• 2017 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2018 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists

Boys Varsity Soccer

• 2015 ACIS Playoff Champions
• 2016 PSAA Playoff Finalists
• 2017 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2018 PSAA Playoff Quarter-finalists

Girls Varsity Tennis

• 2016 Undefeated CHSAA Regular Season and Tournament Champions
• 2017 Undefeated CHSAA Regular Season and Tournament Champions
• 2018 Undefeated CHSAA Regular Season and Tournament Champions

Boys Varsity Tennis

• 2017 ACIS Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2018 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2019 ACIS Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2019 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists

Girls Varsity Volleyball

• 2017 PSAA Playoff Quarter-finalists

Girls Junior Varsity Volleyball

• 2017 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2018 ACIS Playoff Semi-finalists

Boys Varsity Volleyball

• 2016 PSAA Regular Season and Playoff Champions
• 2017 PSAA Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2018 PSAA Playoff Finalists
• 2019 PSAA Regular Season Co-Champions
• 2019 PSAA Playoff Finalists

Girls Varsity Basketball

• 2015 NYS Federation 'B' Champions
• 2016 NYS Federation “A” Champions
• 2017 NYS Federation “A” Champions
• 2018 NYS Federation “A” Semi-Finalists
• 2019 NYS Federation "A" Finalists

Boys Varsity Basketball

• 2018 ACIS Regular Season Champions
• 2018 ACIS Playoff Finalists
• 2018 NYSAIS Class "C" Semi-finalists
• 2019 ACIS Playoff Semi-finalists
• 2019 NYSAIS Class "C" Semi-finalists

Girls Junior Varsity Basketball

• 2017 PSAA Regular Season Champions
• 2017 PSAA Playoff Finalists
• 2018 PSAA Playoff Finalists
• 2019 PSAA Playoff Finalists

Boys Junior Varsity Basketball

• 2017 ACIS Regular Season Co-Champions
• 2017 ACIS Playoff Champions

Girls Varsity Lacrosse

• 2017 PSAA Playoff Finalists
• 2018 PSAA Playoff Finalists

• Zachary Z. ’19 became the second male and only the third SIA student-athlete (along with Bethany C. ’12 and Mike K. '18) to win the prestigious Varsity Club Award, presented to the top male and female student-athletes on Staten Island.
• In the 2018 fall season, Julia L. ’20 won her third consecutive SICHSAA Girls Tennis Singles title. This marked the seventh year in a row in which an SIA player has earned this title (Jillian A. ’16 won 4 consecutive titles from 2012-2015).
• Head Coach Anthony Pisciottano was named PSAA Boys Soccer Coach of the Year in 2018.
• 25 SIA athletes have been recruited to play either Division I, II or III athletics in college over the past 5 years.
• Sophia D. ’19 became the 2018-2019 Jaques Award winner, given to the top female high school basketball player on Staten Island. This was Sophia's second consecutive year winning this coveted award, which has now gone to a member of the SIA Girls Varsity Basketball Team for the last 5 years (Corinn B. ’16 in 2015 and 2016; Clare M. ’17 in 2017).
• Emily L. ’19 and Sophia D. '19 became members of Staten Island’s 1,000 point club, as the senior duo helped lead the Girls Varsity Basketball Team to a berth in the NYS Federation Class A title game.
• Emily L. '19 was named to the 2019 NYS Federation Class “A” All-Tournament Team and also earned the Joan E. Gumb Golden Eagle award, given to a senior girl basketball player on Staten Island who exhibits leadership, consistency, competitiveness, and perseverance.
• Francesca M. '19 earned the 2019 NYS Federation Class A Basketball Tournament of Champions Dr. Bob Kana Sportsmanship Award.
• The Boys Varsity Basketball Team earned its 8th consecutive berth in the prestigious NYSAIS postseason tournament.  The boys advanced to the semifinals of this year's tournament. 
• The Tigers' inaugural Swim Team had a memorable season in 2018-2019.  Three of its members -- Erica M. '24, Joseph D. '23, and Ricky K. '22 -- were selected to participate in the postseason NYSAIS Invitational Swim Championship. 
• Erica M. '24 shattered the pool record in the 500 Freestyle at an ISAL meet at Leman Manhattan.  Her time of 5:01.62 shaved 90 seconds off the previous fastest time by a female swimmer and more than 30 seconds off the fastest time ever recorded by a male swimmer in the pool.
• SIA’s 1st flight golfer, Zachary Z. '19, won the ACIS Golf Tournament Championship Individual title and helped lead the team to a second place finish overall in the league playoff.  Zachary also earned 2nd place in the PSAA Golf Tournament Individual Championship.  
• Kaleigh M. ’19 won the PSAA Golf Tournament Girls Individual title in the 2016, 2018, and 2019 seasons.